top of page

I Play Rocky

Star_rating_0_of_5 (1).png
November 16, 2026
By:
Hunter Friesen
  • Instagram
  • Letterboxd
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Instead of its current title, the newest film from director Peter Farrelly, the unofficial chronicler of oversimplified American history (Green Book, The Greatest Beer Run Ever) and king of dick jokes (Dumb and Dumber, Ricky Stanicky, Balls Up), should have been called I Like Rocky. The title reflects the complicated relationship I had with this film, whose depiction of the origins of both Sylvester Stallone and Rocky Balboa adheres so closely to the source material that the two become nearly impossible to separate. Like just about everyone else, I like 1976's Best Picture winner Rocky, a film whose heart and sincerity make every underdog feel like a champion. Is my affection for I Play Rocky simply a Pavlovian response to seeing moment from Rocky projected on a big screen? Perhaps. But that would overlook the fact that I Play Rocky is also a genuine crowd-pleaser, well-acted, and one of the funniest comedies of the year.


Stepping into the shoes (and boxing gloves) of a young Sylvester Stallone is Long Island native Anthony Ippolito, who seems poised to corner the market on portraying the early years of famous Italian American actors. After previously playing a young Al Pacino during the making of The Godfather in the Paramount+ miniseries The Offer, Ippolito once again proves himself remarkably adept at inhabiting larger-than-life figures. Should a Robert De Niro or James Gandolfini biopic ever be commissioned, I would wager his name appears near the top of the casting shortlist, though he would need to do some serious bulking up to play the latter. He is a star in the making, uncannily resembling Stallone down to the smallest detail. At several points, his performance makes it nearly impossible to tell where archival recreations end and the real film begin.



Initially going by "Mike" because his alliterative birth name exacerbates his speech impediment, we first meet Stallone struggling to realize his dream of becoming an actor. He can’t even land auditions for roles like "Thug #2," parts that would seem tailor-made for someone with his muscular build, distinctly Italian features, and gravelly voice. After spending a night on the streets, he befriends an abandoned dog named Butkus. Adding a touch of mythmaking to Stallone's underdog story, screenwriter Peter Gamble has him land a softcore pornography role thanks to his impressive physical asset, allowing him to “upgrade” to a dingy apartment sandwiched between a rundown church and an X-rated movie theater.


Enter Sasha (AnnaSophia Robb), who looks beyond Sly’s exterior to recognize his intelligence, ambition, and talent. Her support encourages him to embrace his real name and begin writing screenplays, the only path she believes will lead to the acting opportunities he craves. The pair become a modern-day Leo and Sophia Tolstoy. Sly spends his nights furiously scribbling drafts by hand, while Sasha types them into proper scripts during the day. The resulting work may lack Tolstoy's literary complexity, but one story possesses poetry of its own: the tale of a Philadelphia boxer who receives a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to fight the heavyweight champion of the world.


The script lands on the desks of producers Robert Chartoff and Irwin Winkler, who are already struggling to keep Martin Scorsese's New York, New York under control. They view Rocky as a star vehicle for names like Steve McQueen or Ryan O'Neal, while Stallone, uttering the film's titular phrase, insists on playing the lead himself. For a substantial portion of the runtime, he repeatedly turns down increasingly lucrative offers to surrender his script, each one containing enough money to transform the lives of Sasha, their unborn child, and himself.



Eventually, the film is greenlit on Stallone's terms, with the brash John G. Avildsen (Jay Duplass) hired to direct. "We'll figure it out" becomes the production's unofficial mantra as the ultra-low-budget shoot endures injuries, mafia-connected unions, and virtually every obstacle imaginable. Drawing on both the real-life history of the production and his own decades of filmmaking experience, Farrelly finds considerable humor in these moments. The result is a reminder that many beloved classics were assembled with little more than duct tape, glue, and an extraordinary amount of luck. A contagious sense of optimism radiates from the screen as a dream slowly becomes reality, inspiring anyone who has ever chased an unlikely ambition.


I Play Rocky is not a particularly complicated movie, nor is it one that will change my life. I go to the movies primarily to have a good time, even if artistic merit and emotional enrichment remain important parts of the equation. To borrow a quote from former Nintendo of America president Reggie Fils-Aimé: "If it's not fun, why bother?" By that metric, I Play Rocky succeeds with flying colors. It is enormously entertaining, sending audiences out of the theater on a high note and ready to take on the world.


This review was originally published from the world premiere at the 2026 Toronto International Film Festival. Amazon MGM Studios will release I Play Rocky in select theaters on November 13th, followed by a nationwide expansion on November 20th.

THG: Sunrise on the Reaping

Star_rating_0_of_5 (1).png
November 17, 2026
By:
Hunter Friesen

I Play Rocky

Star_rating_0_of_5 (1).png
November 16, 2026
By:
Hunter Friesen

How to Rob a Bank

Star_rating_0_of_5 (1).png
November 11, 2026
By:
Hunter Friesen

Being Heumann

Star_rating_0_of_5 (1).png
November 12, 2026
By:
Hunter Friesen
Hunter Friesen
bottom of page