After a quadrilogy, a prequel, and now a sequel-prequel, The Hunger Games saga remains alive and well on the big screen. It's no surprise that it's still thriving, given how author Suzanne Collins' source novels continue to resonate in an increasingly politically fractured and consolidated world. The Hunger Games themselves are bread for the poor districts and circuses for the wealthy Capitol. It is the rebels versus the empire, the Fremen versus the Harkonnens, the humans versus the machines, Spartacus versus the Romans. With Sunrise on the Reaping, Collins focuses on the psychology of submission among the downtrodden, exploring how so few can govern so many so cruelly. The oppressed cannot imagine themselves ever being free, their chains feeling like an inevitable part of life. To break free physically, one must first break free mentally.
As is tradition within the franchise, the runt of the litter is District 12, an Appalachian-inspired region of Panem populated by poor residents who often work as miners, millers, or moonshiners. Among them is Haymitch Abernathy (Joseph Zada), a young man scraping by each day to support his widowed mother and younger brother while finding solace in hardship through his girlfriend, Lenore Dove Baird. Haymitch's belief in the certainty of tyranny is reinforced by the fact that the annual reaping always falls on his birthday. The only celebration he receives is hearing his name passed over so he can live another year. This year, however, marks the fiftieth Hunger Games, prompting four tributes to be selected from each district instead of the usual two. After a small altercation with Peacekeeper guards, Haymitch is chosen as one of District 12's tributes. Alongside the three others selected, the odds are certainly not in their favor.
This is a routine we've experienced more than once. A sympathetic and unlikely tribute is selected from District 12 and separated from their loved ones. They are paraded before the cameras, extravagantly dressed and instructed in the rules of a game designed by the wealthy elite. The “Careers” from the richer districts are brash and boastful, while the long shots from poorer regions are picked off one by one inside an arena packed with deadly surprises. Our hero refuses to treat violence as the sole means of survival, relying instead on ingenuity to become an unlikely symbol of hope for the small flames of resistance.
As familiar as this formula feels, it is both a strength and a liability for Sunrise on the Reaping. Its greatest asset remains its cast. From Jennifer Lawrence and Josh Hutcherson to Tom Blyth and Rachel Zegler, this franchise has consistently found young performers capable of carrying major blockbusters. Stepping into that tradition is Zada, a relatively unknown television actor who brings considerably more depth to Haymitch than the conventional hero's journey provided by writers Billy Ray and Michael Lesslie.
He will eventually become Woody Harrelson from the original films, just as Kieran Culkin evolves into Stanley Tucci's Caesar Flickerman, Elle Fanning into Elizabeth Banks' Effie Trinket, Ralph Fiennes into Donald Sutherland's President Snow, and Jesse Plemons into Philip Seymour Hoffman's Plutarch Heavensbee. Each performance feels like a natural extension of its predecessor, though Kelvin Harrison Jr. stands out in particular, delivering an uncannily convincing younger version of Jeffrey Wright's Beetee Latier. One of the few entirely new characters is Glenn Close's Drusilla Sickle, the escort for District 12's tributes, who struts about in hideously bright outfits with her face pulled taut, as if she had undergone the skin-stretching procedure from Terry Gilliam's Brazil.
Plutarch serves as the producer of the Games, shaping events into whatever narrative best supports the Capitol's propaganda. When the Capitol intentionally draws Haymitch's name during the reaping, Plutarch edits the broadcast to make it look completely random. Later, he delays Haymitch's final goodbye with his family until the cameras are rolling, manufacturing the emotional spectacle that makes for good television. His tools are handheld cameras and low-tech surveillance equipment, with production designer Uli Hanisch evoking the political thrillers of the 1970s, a period when many Americans began to distrust the stories being presented to them by the media. As Plutarch notes, "Presentation is everything," while the truth remains infinitely malleable.

Sunrise on the Reaping certainly practices what it preaches when it comes to presentation. Veteran franchise director Francis Lawrence once again employs the IMAX aspect ratio during the arena sequences. This time, the setting evokes Midsommar, with sun-drenched vistas that are as beautiful as they are dangerous. Like the poorly rendered CGI animals that inhabit it, that beauty is ultimately a facade, designed to lure tributes into traps meant to break them down and turn them into killers. One of Haymitch's closest allies is fellow District 12 tribute Maysilee Donner (McKenna Grace), whose companionship provides a much-needed source of comfort as the nightly cannon blasts signal another round of deaths.
Like The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes, the film adopts a chapter structure, with each title gradually revealing its significance over the course of the story. Unfortunately, it repeats its predecessor's biggest mistake by saving its weakest chapter for last. The final stretch slows proceedings to a crawl and repeatedly emphasizes themes the audience has already understood. At the very least, Sunrise on the Reaping learns from some of its predecessor's excesses, streamlining its efforts to fit the square peg into the circular hole that is the connective tissue of the larger franchise mythology. My hunger has been satisfied after all these films. At this point, I’d say it’s time to quit while we’re ahead and stop playing these games.
Lionsgate will release The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping in theaters nationwide on November 20th
